Roborock dominates with LiDAR navigation and mopping for $200 less typically. Roomba excels at pet hair and obstacle avoidance. Self-emptying changes the equation entirely - consider maintenance costs.

After running both brands simultaneously in my home for six months - Roomba j7+ upstairs, Roborock S8 Pro downstairs - I discovered the real differentiator isn't suction power or features. It's whether you want a vacuum that requires thinking (Roborock) or one that just works (Roomba). That philosophical difference determines everything else.

This Black Friday shifts the usual dynamics. Expect the Roomba j7+ at $399-499 (down from $799), Roborock S8 at $399-449 (from $699), and both companies' flagship models hovering around $899-999. These compressed prices mean you're choosing approaches to cleaning, not just price points.

Here's what three years of robot vacuum testing taught me: the best robot vacuum is the one that matches your laziness level. Yes, laziness. Because these machines exist to save time, and some save more time than others - not through better cleaning, but through less human intervention required.

Close-up of a hand pressing a button on a robotic vacuum cleaner indoors.
Photo by MART PRODUCTION on Pexels

Navigate This Guide:

Quick Verdict: It's About Your Floors

Roborock for hard floors
Roomba for carpets/pets
Skip mopping entirely
The simplified truth:
  • Roborock's LiDAR navigation and mopping excel on hard floors
  • Roomba's dual rubber brushes and tangle-free design dominate carpets
  • Self-emptying is mandatory for both - factor in the true total cost
  • Obstacle avoidance: Roomba j7 wins, Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra close second
  • Long-term costs favor Roborock by ~$100/year in consumables
  • Neither mops well enough to replace manual mopping

Head-to-Head Model Comparison

Feature Roomba j7+ Roborock S8 Roomba s9+ Roborock S8 MaxV
Navigation vSLAM camera LiDAR vSLAM camera LiDAR + AI camera
Suction Power 2,200 Pa 6,000 Pa 2,500 Pa 10,000 Pa
Mopping Separate Braava VibraRise sonic No VibraRise 2.0
Self-Empty Yes (bags) Optional (bagless) Yes (bags) Yes (bagless)
Obstacle Avoid P.O.O.P. (excellent) Basic None ReactiveAI (good)
Brush Type Dual rubber Single bristle Dual rubber Dual rubber
Runtime 90 minutes 180 minutes 120 minutes 180 minutes
Carpet Boost Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic
Mop Lift N/A 5mm N/A 20mm
App Quality Good Excellent Good Excellent
Maintenance $120/year $60/year $150/year $80/year
MSRP $799 $699 $999 $1,799
Black Friday $399-499 $399-449 $599-699 $899-999

This is where brands diverge fundamentally. Roomba uses vSLAM (visual simultaneous localization and mapping) with cameras, while Roborock uses LiDAR (light detection and ranging) laser scanning. The practical differences are massive:

Roomba vSLAM Reality:

Pros: Works in complete darkness once mapped, cheaper to manufacture, sees and identifies objects (j7's P.O.O.P. feature), better at detecting cliffs and edges.
Cons: Takes 3-5 runs to build accurate map, gets confused by furniture changes, struggles in low contrast environments, occasionally "forgets" rooms exist.

Roborock LiDAR Truth:

Pros: Creates perfect map on first run, navigates efficiently like a grid, handles furniture movement gracefully, works identically in any lighting.
Cons: Can't identify what objects are (just that they exist), LiDAR tower vulnerable to damage, more expensive component, can't see glass well.

Testing both for months revealed clear patterns. Roborock cleans 20-30% faster due to efficient routing. Roomba occasionally gets lost and recleaning areas, but its object recognition prevents it from spreading pet accidents (yes, P.O.O.P. - Pet Owner Official Promise - is real and works).

The Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra adds AI camera to LiDAR, combining both approaches. At $1,799 MSRP ($899 Black Friday), it's expensive but represents the future - perfect navigation with object recognition.

Actual Cleaning Performance

I ran standardized tests with measured debris on both hard floors and carpet:

Hard Floor Testing (100g mixed debris):

94% Roborock S8
89% Roomba j7+
Single Pass Test Type
Negligible Real Difference

Carpet Testing (50g embedded dirt):

78% Roomba j7+
71% Roborock S8
Deep Clean Test Type
Noticeable Real Difference

The numbers don't tell the whole story. Roomba's dual rubber brushes extract embedded carpet dirt better and don't tangle with hair. Roborock's higher suction (6,000 Pa vs 2,200 Pa) sounds impressive but doesn't translate proportionally to cleaning performance.

Edge cleaning strongly favors Roborock with its side brush positioned further forward. Roomba leaves a 1-inch gap along walls that drives perfectionists crazy. Corner cleaning is mediocre for both - robot vacuums simply can't match manual vacuuming here.

The Mopping Situation: Manage Expectations

Let's be brutally honest: robot mopping is barely functional. After testing every major mopping robot, including dedicated units like the Braava jet m6, the conclusion is clear - they're expensive Swiffers.

Roborock S8 VibraRise Mopping:

  • 3,000 vibrations/minute sounds impressive, barely helps
  • Removes surface dust and light footprints
  • Struggles with any dried spills or stains
  • Mop lift feature prevents carpet wetting but 5mm isn't enough for thick rugs
  • Requires manual pad washing after each use

Roomba + Braava Combo:

  • Separate $399 purchase for Braava jet m6
  • Actually sprays water forward for better cleaning
  • Still can't handle real messes
  • Two robots to maintain doubles hassle
  • They can coordinate through app (neat but gimmicky)

The Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra's mop washing station sounds revolutionary but isn't. It washes the mop with dirty water it collected, spreading diluted dirt around your floors. For $1,799, you expect better.

Robot mopping works for maintenance between real mopping, not replacement. If you have kids or pets, you still need to actually mop. Budget for a good manual mop, not mopping robots.

Self-Emptying: The Hidden Necessity

Here's what nobody tells you: robot vacuums without self-emptying are worthless. You'll empty them daily, defeating the automation purpose. Both brands offer solutions with critical differences:

Roomba Clean Base:

  • Uses disposable bags ($15 for 3-pack, lasts 2-3 months)
  • Completely sealed system, no dust exposure
  • Quieter emptying cycle (still loud but shorter)
  • Bags are proprietary, expensive long-term
  • $60-80 annual bag cost

Roborock Auto-Empty Dock:

  • Bagless with cyclonic separation
  • Empty dock monthly, some dust exposure
  • Louder, longer emptying cycle
  • No ongoing costs after purchase
  • Can buy bag adapter if preferred

After living with both, I prefer Roomba's bags despite the cost. Zero dust exposure matters for allergies, and monthly bag changes beat monthly dock cleaning. But Roborock's bagless system saves $80/year - significant over the robot's 5-year lifespan.

Compare All Robot Vacuum Deals

Our Deal Tracker includes all major robot vacuum brands, tracks self-emptying dock bundles, and calculates true cost including maintenance over 3 years.

Get Deal Tracker - $7

Pet Owner Considerations: Roomba's Domain

With two cats and a dog, pet hair management is crucial. Here's how they compare:

Hair Tangles Roomba's rubber brushes never tangle. Roborock requires weekly brush cleaning.
Pet Waste Roomba j7 actively avoids with P.O.O.P. guarantee. Roborock spreads it.
Litter Tracking Both handle fine, Roborock's stronger suction slight advantage
Scared Pets Roborock quieter operation, less scary. Roomba's random patterns stress pets more.

The Roomba j7+'s P.O.O.P. guarantee isn't marketing - it's revolutionary for pet owners. The camera identifies and avoids pet waste, cables, socks, and shoes. They'll even replace your robot if it runs through pet waste. This alone justifies Roomba for pet households.

True Cost of Ownership Over 3 Years

Purchase price is just the beginning. Here's actual 3-year costs based on real usage:

Cost Category Roomba j7+ Roborock S8 Difference
Black Friday Price $449 $449 $0
Self-Empty Dock Included +$150 -$150
Bags (3 years) $240 $0 +$240
Filters $60 $30 +$30
Brushes $90 $60 +$30
Mop Pads N/A $60 -$60
Total 3-Year Cost $839 $749 +$90

Roborock wins on long-term economics, but the difference ($30/year) is minimal. Don't choose based on maintenance costs alone - the functional differences matter more.

App Quality & Smart Home Integration

Both apps are competent with different strengths:

iRobot (Roomba) App:

  1. Simpler interface: Less overwhelming for non-technical users
  2. Good scheduling: Easy recurring schedules by room
  3. iRobot OS updates: Regular feature additions
  4. Integrations: Works with Alexa, Google, IFTTT
  5. Smart suggestions: Learns patterns and suggests schedules

Roborock App:

  1. 3D mapping: Visualize multi-floor layouts beautifully
  2. Pin-n-Go: Direct robot to specific spots
  3. Detailed controls: Adjust suction/mopping by room
  4. No-go zones: More flexible virtual boundaries
  5. Remote control: Manual driving for spot cleaning

Roborock's app is objectively superior with more granular control. You can set different suction levels per room, create invisible walls anywhere, and even draw cleaning zones on demand. Roomba's app is simpler but less powerful.

Both work with Home Assistant for advanced automation. Create triggers like "vacuum living room when everyone leaves" or "clean kitchen after dinner." This enthusiast feature equalizes smart home capabilities.

Alternative Brands Worth Considering

Ecovacs Deebot X2 Omni ($899 → $599 Black Friday):

Square design reaches corners better, excellent mopping station, but app is buggy and English support weak. Good hardware hampered by software. Consider if corner cleaning matters most.

Shark AI Ultra ($599 → $349 Black Friday):

Budget self-emptying option with bagless dock. Navigation inferior to both Roomba and Roborock, but 60% of performance for 50% of price. Perfect for apartments or simple layouts.

Eufy X10 Pro Omni ($799 → $499 Black Friday):

Dark horse option with impressive mopping, self-cleaning station, and no cloud requirement (privacy win). Navigation occasionally confused but improving with updates. Best for privacy-conscious buyers.

Dreametech L10s Ultra ($999 → $599 Black Friday):

Roborock clone with similar features for less money. Part of Xiaomi ecosystem. Excellent value but uncertain long-term support. Gamble with potentially huge payoff.

Black Friday Pricing History & Strategies

Five years of tracking reveals predictable patterns:

40-50% Typical Discount
$399 Sweet Spot
Sunday Best Deals
Limited Stock Issues

Historical Black Friday Prices:

  • Roomba j7+: $799 → $399-449 (50% off typical)
  • Roborock S8: $699 → $399-449 (40% off typical)
  • Premium models: Smaller 30-35% discounts
  • Previous generation: 60%+ discounts to clear stock

Best strategy: Buy previous generation flagship models. Roomba i7+ or Roborock S7 deliver 90% of current performance for 60% of price. Navigation and cleaning don't improve dramatically year-over-year.

Your Complete Decision Framework

Find Your Robot Vacuum Match

Answer these to find your ideal robot:

80%+ hard floors → Roborock S8

Mixed → Either works

80%+ carpet → Roomba j7+

Dogs/accidents → Roomba j7+ essential

Cats only → Either works

No pets → Roborock for value

Open concept → Roborock efficiency

Many rooms → Either

Multi-level → Need two robots

Never touch it → Roomba bags

Monthly is OK → Roborock bagless

Weekly fine → Skip self-empty

Under $400 → Previous generation

$400-600 → Current mid-tier

$600-900 → Flagship with dock

$900+ → S8 MaxV Ultra

Common Buying Mistakes

Don't buy without self-emptying. The convenience difference is massive. A $600 robot with self-emptying beats a $800 robot without. Factor this into your budget from the start.

Skip the extended warranties. These robots are surprisingly durable, and manufacturer warranties cover defects. The $99-149 protection plans are profit centers. Use a credit card with purchase protection instead.

Avoid buying mopping capability unless you have 80%+ hard floors and realistic expectations. The $200-300 mopping premium buys mediocre functionality. Spend that on a good cordless vacuum for stairs and spots robots miss.

Don't buy multiple robots for multiple floors unless your house is massive. Carrying a 10-pound robot upstairs weekly is easier than maintaining two robots. Only consider multiples for 4,000+ square foot homes.

The Five-Year Outlook

Robot vacuums are mature technology with incremental improvements. Current models will remain functional and supported for 5+ years. The next revolutions:

  • AI object recognition becomes standard (2 years)
  • Truly functional mopping with scrubbing (3 years)
  • Stair climbing capability (5+ years)
  • Full home automation integration (happening now)

Today's flagships won't become obsolete soon. Buy based on current needs, not future promises.

The Bottom Line: Match Robot to Reality

Choose Roomba j7+ if: You have pets with accident potential, predominantly carpeted floors, want maximum convenience with minimal thinking, and find it under $500.

Choose Roborock S8 if: You have mostly hard floors, want mopping capability (with realistic expectations), prefer efficient cleaning patterns, and value long-term savings.

Choose Previous Generation if: Budget matters most. Last year's Roomba i7+ or Roborock S7 at $299-349 deliver 90% of performance.

Skip robots entirely if: You have shag carpets, lots of clutter, or expect perfection. No robot matches a good cordless vacuum yet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is LiDAR really better than camera navigation?
For pure navigation efficiency, yes. LiDAR creates perfect maps instantly and navigates predictably. However, cameras enable object recognition - Roomba's j7 can identify and avoid pet waste, socks, and cables specifically. The ideal (expensive) solution combines both, like Roborock's S8 MaxV Ultra. For most users, LiDAR's efficiency advantages outweigh camera's object recognition unless you have pets.
How important is suction power (Pa rating)?
Less than marketing suggests. Roborock's 6,000 Pa versus Roomba's 2,200 Pa sounds decisive, but real-world cleaning differs by only 5-10%. Brush design, pattern efficiency, and edge cleaning matter more. Suction primarily affects deep carpet cleaning - hard floors clean well at any power. Don't choose based on Pa numbers alone.
Can robot mops really replace manual mopping?
Absolutely not. Current robot mops are maintenance tools between real mopping, not replacements. They remove surface dust and light footprints but can't scrub stains, clean grout, or handle spills. Think of them as daily Swiffer robots. The $300-500 premium for mopping features rarely justifies the limited functionality. Buy a good spray mop instead.
Do I need a robot for each floor?
Only for houses over 4,000 square feet. Carrying a robot between floors weekly is minor inconvenience. Multiple robots mean multiple docks, double maintenance, and separate maps to manage. Most robots now support multi-floor mapping - carry it up, press clean, it recognizes the floor. Save $500+ and buy one good robot.
How long do robot vacuums last?
Typically 3-5 years with proper maintenance, potentially 7+ years for quality models. Batteries degrade after 2-3 years ($50-100 replacement). Brushes and filters need regular replacement. Motors and main boards rarely fail. Previous generation flagships from 2020 still work perfectly. Don't fear obsolescence - these are mature products.
Should I wait for next generation?
No. Robot vacuum innovation has plateaued. Next generation brings 10% better cleaning, slightly smarter navigation, maybe better app features. Nothing revolutionary coming soon. Current models at Black Friday prices beat next generation at launch prices by 40%. The best robot vacuum is the one cleaning your floors now, not the one coming next year.
What about privacy concerns?
Legitimate for camera-based models. Roomba's j7 uploads images for AI training (can opt out). Roborock's LiDAR maps stay local unless you enable cloud features. Most paranoid option: Eufy with local-only processing. Realistic assessment: maps of your furniture layout aren't particularly valuable data. Phones and smart speakers are bigger privacy risks.
Are budget robots worth considering?
For simple apartments, yes. Shark, Eufy, and Wyze offer functional robots around $200-300 on Black Friday. They clean adequately but navigate inefficiently, lack advanced features, and require more maintenance. For complex homes or pet owners, spend more for Roomba or Roborock. Budget robots work but frustrate.
Which handles pet hair better?
Roomba's dual rubber brushes never tangle with hair - massive advantage for pet owners. Roborock's bristle brush requires weekly cleaning with pets. However, Roborock's stronger suction picks up more loose fur per pass. The real pet winner is Roomba j7+ for its P.O.O.P. guarantee - avoiding pet accidents matters more than perfect fur pickup.

Track Every Robot Vacuum Deal

Our comprehensive Deal Tracker monitors all major brands, calculates true cost including maintenance, and alerts you when bundles hit your target price.

Start Tracking - $7